The keeper’s policy on holding applications in abeyance
Introduction
Under the Land Registration (Scotland) Act 1979, the keeper’s usual practice was to hold applications for registration in abeyance when she was made aware of an issue that may affect a title, typically the risk of a court action relating to the validity of a title.
The Keeper has decided to stop this practice and adopt the undernoted policies for dealing with applications under the Land Registration etc. (Scotland) Act 2012 in such circumstances.
2012 Act applications
There will always be a window between acceptance of an application and completion of registration, but the keeper expects that the changes brought in by the 2012 Act will reduce the length of that gap.
The new policy applies where the keeper is aware, or becomes aware during the gap period, of a matter such as a pending court action that might in the past have led her to hold an application in abeyance.
All such applications will be accepted or rejected within the standard period allowed for the dealing in question.
If the deed presented for registration is potentially voidable, the application will be processed as normal because the deed is good until reduced and a decree of reduction is under the 2012 Act an event that gives rise to registration rather than rectification.
If the deed presented for registration is potentially void, then the Keeper will decide on the balance of probabilities whether the deed:-
- is valid, and if so complete registration as normal
- is invalid, and if so reject the application
- is valid but significant doubt1 remains, in which case she will register but limit the warranty
The keeper considers that there must be more than just a suspicion of invalidity in order for there to be a significant doubt as to the validity of a title.
So for example the keeper may not give much weight to an unsubstantiated telephone call from a member of the public alleging that a deed is void, for example, but may give considerable weight to a letter from a person acting in an official capacity such as the Accountant in Bankruptcy setting out why she considers that a deed is void.
However, this policy may be departed from on a case-by-case basis.
Footnote
1. Significant doubt. There has to be more than simply a suspicion on the part of the Keeper. There requires to be some evidence to support a suspicion. An unsubstantiated telephone call from a member of the public alleging that a deed is void, for example, would not give rise to “significant doubt”. But a letter from a person acting in an official capacity (a solicitor, the Law Society, the AiB, for example) setting out that there are reasons to believe that a deed presented for registration is flawed, would give rise to doubt significant enough to justify limiting warranty